Religious discrimination: Christian teacher’s dismissal for refusal to divorce sex offender
The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has held that a Christian employee, dismissed for not divorcing her husband when he was convicted of sex offences, was subjected to indirect religious discrimination.
In Pendleton v Derbyshire County Council and another, the EAT held that the dismissal of a Christian employee because of her refusal to end her marriage with a convicted sex offender was indirect religious discrimination.
Christian belief in sanctity of marriage: EAT’s view
“The tensions that she suffered given the difficulties arising from her belief and the election forced upon her…inevitably mean that there would be a particular (collective) disadvantage for others holding the same belief…
“I do not suggest that any less respect should be given for those who are in a loving and committed relationship (whether married or not) but who do not share the same view as the claimant as to the sanctity of marriage vows; I am simply recognising that… those sharing the claimant’s belief would suffer a particular disadvantage given the crisis of conscience they would face.”
Mrs Pendleton, a Christian, was a teacher. Her husband, a teacher at another school, was convicted of making indecent images of children and sentenced to 10 months in prison.
It was accepted that Mrs Pendleton had no prior knowledge of, or involvement in, her husband’s behaviour.
Mrs Pendleton chose to stay with her husband. Her decision was based on her Christian belief in the sanctity of her marriage vows. She maintained that she had done nothing wrong, was a separate person to her husband, had an exemplary track record in safeguarding and did not present a risk.
The school at which she worked summarily dismissed her on the basis that she had “chosen to maintain a relationship with [her] partner who has been convicted of making indecent images of children”.
The disciplinary panel stated that her decision had cast doubt on her suitability to carry out safeguarding responsibilities and choices in her personal life contravened the school’s ethos. Mrs Pendleton won her subsequent unfair dismissal claim, but her indirect religious discrimination claim failed at first instance, but was upheld on appeal.
The EAT concluded that those with a religious belief in the sanctity of marriage face a particular disadvantage when they are asked by their employer to divorce their partner.
It held that the school’s stance could not be justified. While ensuring the safety of children is a legitimate aim, the decision to dismiss Mrs Pendleton was not a proportionate means of achieving the aim. The school had not considered alternatives to dismissal. The tribunal set aside the original tribunal decision on discrimination, and substituted a finding of indirect religious discrimination.
“I would like to say how helpful, supportive and knowledgeable you have been throughout my whole wrongful disciplinary and subsequent ACAS procedure I have been through. Your responses to anything I have sent have been quick, professional and of such high quality, making me feel reassured in my position. Excellent all round, very much appreciated. Thank you”
Always available, aways solid and dependable advice. Thank you very much.
“I have worked closely with Gail and Clare for over 4 years, after they took over our HR and then our payroll. What I appreciate most is the personal service they provide, I can always pick up the phone and chat through any issues at any time. If I have a concern I am immediately reassured by their professional and approachable manner. I always feel that our school is their priority and our staff are real people to them, not just a payroll number.
Both Clare and Gail bend over backwards to fit into our schedules and provide a quick, accurate service. I would wholeheartedly recommend their brilliant professional, friendly service.”
“About 18 months ago we approached Gail Escolme Legal with regard to providing payroll services, as they already provided us with HR services. The professionalism and the way they handled the transfer from our existing provider was outstanding. Gail and Clare were there every step of the way guiding us through the process and ensuring a smooth transition.
In the twelve months they have been handling our payroll, the service we have received has been exceptional, something they consider to be the ‘norm’. Gail and Clare are always willing to help with any queries we have, including issues which were outstanding from our previous provider. They have certainly made my life easier in terms of processing payroll which is down to their dedication to getting things right first time.”
“When facing a business contract termination with potential issues, Gail helped me with advice for my preliminary meetings and then support through the early stages of my communications with the company concerned. As the case escalated to a more formal pressing of my claim, Gail took over the communication with expert advice and negotiation skills and finally a successful conclusion. I have no hesitation in recommending Gail Escolme Employment Law and am grateful for all Gail’s help and support in my case.”
CB Endmoor – Contract dispute
“Over the years we have built a positive working relationship with Gail, dealing with our own internal employment law issues and also by introducing Gail to our clients to assist them with their issues. We have always found her advice practical and efficient, delivered in a professional but understandable way. I personally have no hesitation in recommending Gail to other businesses”.
“We have worked very successfully with Gail Escolme over a number of years on personnel issues. We prefer to handle most of this work in house, but where extra external professional advice is thought necessary Gail is always our first stop. This has resulted in a very cost effective approach to personnel management, but with the confidence of an experienced professional behind the scenes. Undoubtedly this has led to a significant improvement in performance across our operating companies and hence profitability and business success”.
Jim Walker Chief Executive Lake District Estates, Ravenglass & Eskdale Railway, Ullswater ‘Steamers’
“Gail has worked with us for several years as our employment law specialist. We appreciate her clear and practical advice which is given in plain English rather than in legal jargon. She is professional but very approachable and having her expertise on hand is very reassuring in the ever changing world of employment legislation.’
Julie Chapman, HR and Finance Director, Castle Green Hotel in Kendal.
“I was very happy with the service. Gail was both efficient and friendly and offered excellent advice. I would be more than happy to use her services again.”
“Thank you for easing my anxiety and providing extremely good advice that was much appreciated.”
“Fantastic, patient service. Would have no hesitation in recommending Gail, brilliant lawyer!”
“Gail completely understood the issues and took away the trauma associated with a redundancy. Many thanks.”
“Gail was able to clearly explain the legal terms to me to enable my understanding. She calmly guided me through what I thought was going to be a scary process and made it seem pleasantly reasonable and easy.”
“Thank you for all your help and support in respect of this matter. Your professionalism and commercial advice were key to a swift and satisfactory conclusion. Being able to contact you out of hours on occasion was a breath of fresh air and your prompt response to emails and calls exceeded all expectations. An excellent, friendly and professional service – I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend you!”
“Many thanks for your help. You have been excellent and I am so glad I found you. you completely understood my situation and took away the stress of the scary process. You provided an excellenet service.”
“100% satisfied. would not hesitate to recommend Gail to anyone.”
“Gail Escolme offers a service that is unparalleled. She always responds to everything promptly and with confidence, positivity and enthusiasm. This gives the client immediate reassurance which is invaluable. I would not hesitate to recommend Gail Escolme Legal to any individual or business.”
“Gail helped me clearly and calmly through a stressful situation. Thank you.”